• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Montreal New York Pizza - Authentic New York Style Slices in Old Montreal

Montreal New York Pizza is a cozy gem located in Old Montreal, known for serving authentic New York–style pizza with a perfect balance of crispy and chewy crust, rich melted cheese, and savory toppings. Priced affordably between $5-$6 a slice, it offers great value for a quick, satisfying meal. The spot suits on-the-go diners, with minimal seating but a quiet upstairs area overlooking the historic street. Friendly staff and efficient service enhance the experience. Whether you’re grabbing a snack or craving a no-fuss, delicious slice, Montreal New York Pizza delivers classic flavors that keep locals and tourists coming back.

Montreal New York Pizza at a glance

  • Address 420 Pl. Jacques-Cartier, Montréal, QC H2Y 3B3, Canada
  • Restaurant type Fast food restaurant , Pizza delivery , Pizza restaurant , Pizza takeaway .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Montreal New York Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

SDQ B
4

When I traveled to the Old town in Montreal , I accidentally found this restaurant and just entred to fill my stomach. Nice restaurant, great taste, busy place but no choice, it’s in tourist area.

alhijra grade 8 and 9
5

Saw the great rating so we picked up a pizza on our way by. Did not disappoint! Quick and friendly staff. Great pizza! Simple but delicious. Will also be great leftovers tomorrow. Highly recommend. If i lived here i would come back often!

Aliyah Malin
4

This is a great quick stop for an easy quick meal. It is perfect for when you’re craving a big slice of New York style pizza, and the seating upstairs was pretty quiet both times I went and you get to overlook the street of Old Montreal. The pizza itself is great and easy, which we really appreciated.

thom M
5

Nice New York style pizza! Great price between 5-6$ a piece for a large slice. Highly recommend for a cheap snack in Old Montreal

Krishna Raj Udupa
5

If you’re looking for a quick, satisfying bite, this pizza joint is a great spot to grab an awesome slice. The pizza was delicious, with perfectly melted cheese that had a rich, savory flavor. The crust was just the right balance of crispy and chewy, making each bite enjoyable. For the price, it’s a fantastic deal, especially given the quality of the pizza. The place itself is quite small, so don’t expect a lot of seating. It’s more of a grab-and-go spot or somewhere to stand and eat your slice. While the lack of space might not suit those looking for a sit-down meal, it works well for anyone in a rush or just craving a quick snack. The service was decent, though nothing extraordinary. The staff got the job done efficiently, and the wait time was minimal, which is always appreciated when you’re on the go. Overall, this spot delivers exactly what you’d hope for from a casual pizza joint: great food at a reasonable price. If you’re in the area and need a quick and tasty bite, it’s worth a stop. Just be prepared to enjoy your slice standing up!

LILY flower
5

The donuts and pizza were absolutely delicious, and the employees provided excellent service. A great experience overall!

Kris Andy
5

**Location: 4/5 Located upstairs in a charming attic space, offering a unique dining experience. **Food Quality: 5/5 Outstanding pizza with fresh ingredients and robust flavors. **Price: 4/5 Reasonably priced for the excellent quality and portion sizes. **Service: 5/5 Exceptional service—friendly, attentive, and efficient. Montreal New York Pizza is a hidden gem for pizza enthusiasts. With delicious pizzas served in a cozy attic setting and top-notch service, it's highly recommended for a satisfying dining experience.

Location

  • Montreal New York Pizza
    Montreal New York Pizza
    420 Pl. Jacques-Cartier, Montréal, QC H2Y 3B3, Canada

Tucked in the heart of Old Montreal, Montreal New York Pizza offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza that’s hard to resist. This spot, located at 420 Pl. Jacques-Cartier, is a bustling little haven for pizza lovers craving large, flavorful slices at an unbeatable price. Each slice boasts a perfect balance of crispy yet chewy crust, topped with rich, savory melted cheese that lingers delightfully with every bite.

The charm of Montreal New York Pizza lies in its simplicity and quality. The quick service and friendly staff make it ideal for anyone on the go or those looking for a satisfying snack without fuss. Though the seating is limited and modest, the upstairs area provides a quieter refuge with a view over the lively streets of Old Montreal, creating a unique and pleasant dining experience.

What stood out most was the consistency of the pizza’s flavor and texture. Whether enjoying a slice fresh or as a next-day leftover, the pizza holds its appeal. The price point—between $5 to $6 per large slice—makes this spot a value-packed find without compromising taste. For travelers and locals alike, this joint delivers just what you want from a casual pizzeria: fast, flavorful slices that leave you eager for the next visit.

In sum, Montreal New York Pizza is a perfect pit stop for those looking for a genuine New York pizza experience right in Montreal’s historic district. I found it to be a delightful blend of quick convenience, classic flavors, and great value—worthy of any pizza enthusiast’s list.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments